QHow is it that Carl and Muntz look about the same age when they meet? Shouldn't Muntz be dead by then?
AThe film skirts around this by never actually saying how old Muntz was when he set off on his journey. He could have been in his early to late 20s or his early 30s. Since Carl was around 10 at the time he saw the news reel of Muntz, and he is apparently 78 at the time he meets Muntz, that means 68 years have passed, meaning Muntz would be in his 90s.
QIs "Up" based on a book?
ANo. Up is a Pixar-animated film, based on an idea by director Pete Docter and a screenplay co-written by co-director Bob Peterson, screenwriter Thomas McCarthy, and animation storyboarder Ronnie del Carmen.
QHow does Russell end up on Carl's porch after his house takes off?
ARussell tells Carl that he was searching for the Snipe under his porch. Later in the movie, after the house is relaunched, Dug also knocks at the door and says that he was hiding under the porch when it took off. Apparently, the porch has a floor underneath which goes with the house when it is airborne. Another possibility is that both Russell and Dug hang on to the underside of the porch when it takes off and then climb up onto the porch in order to get inside the house. In the short film "George & A.J." an attempt is made to handwave this by showing Russell bracing himself underneath the house as it takes off.
Share this