ASeason 1: Amanda Marsh was chosen by Alex MichelSeason 2: Helene Eksterowicz was chosen by Aaron BuergeSeason 3: Jen Schefft was chosen by Andrew FirestoneSeason 4: Estella Gardinier was chosen by Bob GuineySeason 5: Jessica Bowlin was chosen by Jesse PalmerSeason 6: Mary Delgado was chosen by Byron VelvickSeason 7: Sarah Brice was chosen by Charlie O'ConnellSeason 8: Sarah Stone was chosen by Travis StorkSeason 9: Jennifer Wilson was chosen by Prince Lorenzo BorgheseSeason 10: Tessa Horst was chosen by Andy BaldwinSeason 11: Neither finalist was chosen by Brad WomackSeason 12: Shayne Lamas was chosen by Matt GrantSeason 13: Melissa Rycroft was chosen by Jason MesnickSeason 14: Vienna Girardi was chosen by Jake PavelkaSeason 15: Emily Maynard was chosen by Brad WomackSeason 16: Courtney Robertson was chosen by Benjamin FlajnikSeason 17: Catherine Giudici was chosen by Sean Lowe