ASeason 1: Ryan Sutter was chosen by Trista RehnSeason 2: Ian McKee was chosen by Meredith PhillipsSeason 3: Neither finalist was chosen by Jen SchefftSeason 4: Jesse Csincsak was chosen by Deanna PappasSeason 5: Ed Swiderski was chosen by Jillian HarrisSeason 6: Roberto Martinez was chosen by Ali FedotowskySeason 7: J.P. Rosenbaum was chosen by Ashley HebertSeason 8: Jef Holm was chosen by Emily Maynard