The Season 2 script was rewritten 4 times with the only constant being that it would star fan favorites from Season 1= Bryan James (Drew), Jessica Osgood (Mallorie) and Ash Nair (Sean).
Soap star Jen Lilley was cast in the series regular role of Oliver's devious step sister Natalie Cardin for the second season. However the role was scrapped in rewrites of the script choosing to focus more on the returning teenage characters.